The Government have published it’s Schools White Paper and it’s SEND Reforms Consultation, setting there proposals for reform across education.
We will continue to update you on the information and our responses to it as well as asking you for your views.
If you would like to give us your thoughts on any aspect of the Reforms, please do email us at enquiries@spcv.org.uk
Please find below the links to the SEND Reforms documents and the White Paper.
SEND reform: putting children and young people first – GOV.UK
Please see here our responses to the Governments’ SEND Reform Consultation.
Email Response:
I am writing on behalf of parent carers of children and young people with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) in Solihull in response to the current SEND Reforms consultation.
Parent carers generally feel that the Children and Families Act 2014 is the right legislative framework. The issue is not the law itself, but the lack of accountability, sufficient funding, workforce training, and robust, transparent decision-making across the SEND system. Families are deeply concerned that the proposed reforms appear to weaken existing rights rather than address the systemic failures that have prevented the current framework from being implemented effectively.
One of the greatest concerns for families is the proposed reduction in legal protections and rights. Parent carers question the purpose of an Inclusion Support Plan (ISP) as a statutory document if there is no independent right of appeal regarding the contents of the plan, and no enforceable statutory duty to deliver the provision specified within it. Removing or weakening these safeguards fundamentally undermines the already poor confidence in the SEND system and risks leaving children and young people without the support they require.
Families are also extremely concerned about proposed changes to the SEND Tribunal process. In particular, the removal of the Tribunal’s powers to name a specific educational provision is deeply troubling. The ability for an independent Tribunal to make binding decisions is one of the few mechanisms families currently have to ensure accountability within the system. Weakening these powers risks increasing inconsistency and reducing confidence that decisions will be made in the best interests of children and young people.
Similarly, parent carers have significant concerns regarding the proposed Specialist Provision Packages. Vague or generic packages of support within EHCPs weaken legal rights and reduce clarity around what support a child or young person is entitled to receive. Children and young people with SEND do not fit into neat categories or boxes. Their needs are individual and often complex, and support must remain personalised and tailored accordingly. Families fear these proposals move away from individualised support towards a standardised system that will fail to meet many children’s needs.
Parent carers are also deeply concerned by the rhetoric surrounding the increased placement of children and young people with more complex needs into mainstream education. While mainstream settings can and do work well for many children when properly supported, for some children and young people mainstream education will never be the right provision. Decisions about placement must remain needs-led, child-centred, and based on individual circumstances rather than driven by policy ambition or financial pressures.
Families do welcome elements of the proposed reforms, particularly the “Experts at Hand” offer, which could provide valuable specialist support and advice to mainstream schools. Additional specialist expertise within schools is strongly supported by parent carers. However, there is considerable concern regarding the three-year funding commitment attached to this proposal. Families fear that just as schools begin embedding and benefiting from this support, the funding may be withdrawn, resulting in another cycle of instability and unmet need.
Finally, parent carers are extremely concerned that their voices are not being meaningfully listened to throughout this process. The decision to announce SEND reforms within the legislative agenda for the next parliamentary session while the consultation remains open has significantly undermined confidence in the process. Likewise, requiring local areas to begin drafting Local Area SEND Reform Plans before the consultation has concluded, and while the existing law, regulations and SEND Code of Practice remain unchanged, gives families little confidence that this consultation is genuinely open to influence.
Parent carers want a SEND system that works effectively for children and young people. Families are not calling for the removal of rights or protections; they are asking for the current legal framework to be properly funded, consistently implemented, and held accountable. Meaningful co-production with families, alongside enforceable rights and transparent decision-making, must remain at the heart of any future reforms.
On behalf of parent carers of children and young people with SEND in Solihull.
Best wishes
Solihull Parent Carer Voice C.I.C.
Responses to Questions:
1 We want children, young people and their families to be involved in making better, evidence‑based decisions about SEND, both in their
local area and across the country. How can we make sure children, young people and their families have a genuine say in these decisions?
Please comment below::
Under the Children and Families Act 2014, children, young people and families already have a voice.
At an individual level, they must be involved in making decisions about the support they require at SEN Support and within assessments for Education, Health and Care Plans and in their reviews. The issue is not whether children and young people have a voice, it is whether their voices are listened to and genuinely ignored, or whether their voices are ignored and do not genuinely influence the decisions that are made about them.
At a strategic level parent carer voices are heard as part of parent carer forums, who listen to the voices of families across the area and represent these in a strategic way to influence service design and delivery. The challenge here is that parent carer forums are not properly resourced to undertake this work, and some parts of the system, despite coproduction and parent carer forums being in law since 2014, do not understand what coproduction is, and a culture in some areas of the system still exists where parent carers are not treated as professionals.
At both an individual and a strategic level there must be enforceability. There is no point in hearing children, young people and families voices if they are then ignored.
2 How can we make sure that high-quality evidence and best practice inform decisions about SEND? Please share examples.
Please respond below::
Making sure that high-quality evidence and best practice inform decisions about SEND is crucial, both at an individual level and for shaping wider systems.
At an individual level, parent carers and young people need to be confident that the support the child/young person receives is evidence based as is going to meet their needs. Often there is a vast amount of evidence about what a child or young person needs, however this can often be ignored in favour of what is easier, cheaper or allows a child to attend a mainstream setting. For instance a child might be pushed into a mainstream school to keep them “included” rather than being supported in a specialist setting where the evidence shows they would thrive. Decision making is not always about what is best for the child, but about convenience or cost.
At a strategic level, the tension between what would be best, and what is affordable is even more challenging. Service redesign and delivery often starts with “what can be done within a cost envelope” rather that what would best meet the needs of children and young people across the local area. Whilst we understand that there is not an unlimited amount of money, making decisions in silo’s based on cost, often pushes costs into other areas of the system for example putting funds into early identification of need and early support often prevents needs from escalating and prevents higher costs in the long run.
It is also essential that qualitative evidence is also considered.
Part one: putting children and young people first
3 How can we ensure that children are best supported by the Universal offer?
Please respond below::
A strong Universal Offer is essential, all too often what should be ordinarily available in schools is a postcode lottery. Children and young people should have access to the same education and support no matter what mainstream setting they attend.
However, at present this is variable across schools, and is based on the financial position of the school and the ethos and culture in the school.
Defining what the Universal offer is, is important, however this must be properly resourced in terms of funding, staffing and training and there must be accountability and enforcement.
SEND parent carers have very little trust that mainstream schools can meet the needs of their children and young people. This starts from the universal offer, and progresses through all levels.
4 How can we ensure that children in the Targeted layer are best supported?
Please respond below::
We do not believe that the system should create more layers, all too often layers become barriers- you have to try each layer and fail before moving onto the next level. We should be looking to put in place the right support, and the right time, in the right place, that best meets the needs of the child/young person. Support should be focused on what the child/young person needs rather than what level they fit into.
Additional support for children and young people must be timely, with no unnecessary bureaucracy and must be joined up between education, health and social care.
There must be seamless transitions between levels and swift access to more support where this is needed. There must be regular reviews of support, that include the child/young person and the parent carers.
It is vital that there are no arbitrary timeframes put in place- a child must not have to sit at a level of support for a mandated period of time if it is clear that this is not working.
There needs to be clear accountability and enforcement to ensure that support is put in place for children and young people.
5 How can we ensure that children in the Targeted Plus layer are best supported?
Please respond below::
The same concerns for the Targeted Layer apply to Targeted Plus. Support must be put in place early to prevent needs escalating. There must be clear accountability and enforcement to ensure that support is put in place for children and young people.
6 How can we ensure that children in the Specialist layer are best supported?
Please respond below::
Children and young people deemed to fit into the Specialist Layer are those described as complex, however with no definition of complex and no detail about how assessment of need will be undertaken.
All children and young people require accurate and detailed assessment of their needs, and clear and early identification of what support is required to meet those needs.
There is a real concern that children and young people will have to “fail” repeatedly through Universal, Targeted and Targeted Plus layers before they are able to get the support that they need.
Support needs to have clear accountability and enforcement to ensure that children and young people’s needs are met.
Part one: putting children and young people first
7 How do you think early years settings, schools, and colleges can best support the mental health and wellbeing of children and young
people?
Please respond below::
If settings support children and young people’s needs at the earliest possible opportunity, there is a lower likelihood they will develop mental health needs. Frequently children and young people’s emotional wellbeing and mental health suffers as a result of needs not being met.
Schools and settings are not mental health services and do not have the expertise or qualifications to be treated as such.
Ensuring support is put in place at the earliest possible opportunity, identifying children and young people’s needs early, so that they have a true understanding of themselves, and working to reduce bullying will reduce risk of children and young people having poor mental health. Wrapping mental health services around schools and settings will then support those who do have mental health needs.
We must be proactive and work to prevent mental health needs wherever possible rather than being reactive.
8 Do you agree that the refreshed ‘areas of development’ will support educators to understand and address barriers to learning and
participation? Please explain your answer.
Please respond below::
No, removing mental health from the areas of needs is a real risk.
Creating an area of need of Executive Function poses real difficulties as there is a lack of understanding as to what this means and what type of needs fall into this category.
Children and young people do not fall into neat boxes, often their needs are complex and sit across multiple areas, in some cases no-one can agree on a primary area of need for a child/young person.
Areas of development to not deliver provision and do not support a child/young person to receive the support they need, instead they label children unnecessarily.
9 What arrangements would best support effective joint working between early years providers, Best Start Family Hubs, health, local
authorities, and parents for children with SEND in the early years?
Please respond below::
Effective joint working requires a clear framework for responsibility and accountability.
It must be clear who should be doing what, when and what happens if it it not done.
There must be clear data-sharing arrangements and clear communication and transparency.
10 How can the early years foundation stage (EYFS) two-year old progress check and the Healthy Child Programme development review be improved so that children’s needs are identified and supported more quickly? Please share examples.
Please respond below::
These checks are an important part of the early identification of need and play a vital part of the system, however there must be clear pathways for the results of these checks to be passed on to education settings, health services and the local authority- there is no point having checks and identifying needs if that information is held in isolation.
There must be a focus on the early identification of need and then how early support is then put into place.
Part one: putting children and young people first
11 What should the top three priority areas be for building and sharing evidence within the National Inclusion Standards?
Please respond below::
Consistency of practice- so that every child/young person has access to the same support, no matter where they live or what setting they attend.
Accountability- ensuring there are clear accountability systems so that support is put into place to meet need at the earliest opportunity.
Prevention- early support to prevent escalation of need, is vital.
12 What are the most important issues for national training to cover, to help support children and young people with SEND?
Please respond below::
Neurodiversity and how to support children and young people in a neuro-affirming manner.
Sensory needs- how to identify sensory difficulties and create sensory friendly environments.
Communication needs- how to communicate is different ways to meet the needs of different children and young people.
Masking.
Burnout.
Anxiety.
Trauma.
Legal Duties
Training must be written in conjunction with those with lived experience.
13 What practical actions can help teachers, educators and leaders manage workload whilst implementing these changes?
Please respond below::
Staff in education settings are already stretched and their workload already unmanageable.
You cannot increase the workload that schools and settings are expected to do without increase the resources and capacity within the workforce.
These means protected time for training, additional teaching staff and support staff in schools.
Additional administrative support.
Importantly protected time for SENCO’s and support for them.
14 How should the Special Educational Needs Coordinator (SENCO) role evolve to better meet the needs of children and young people with SEND?
Please respond below::
SENCO’s are often expected to do multiple roles and have little protected time. Under the proposed reforms their workload will increase and this is not sustainable.
Settings should have protected SENCO time and resource- there should be a national standard as to how much SENCO time a setting should have based on the number of children and young people their setting has. This time should be protected.
SENCO’s must have the support in place to be able to do their role and proper training, not just the current SENCO qualification, but deeper training around different types of needs and strategies that can support needs. Training around how to work with, and coproduce with children, young people and families and training around person-centred planning.
Part two: new Targeted and Targeted Plus support that is written into law
15 What would provide assurance for families that an Individual Support Plan (ISP) is high quality and contains the essential information?
Please respond below::
There is not point putting in place a statutory document, if there is not accountability for the content of the plan and the delivery of the content.
Families need reassurance that they can appeal the content and the delivery through independent means- families do not trust that a school complaint process, even with an SEND expert on the panel is robust enough to do this.
Children and young people currently on SEN Support, typically have a plan (although called many different names) yet families currently do not have trust in these plans, which leads to the increase in requests for Education, Health and Care Plans. Creating a new document with no accountability will not change confidence in the system.
There needs to be a framework for who will input into these plans- is it just a teacher or someone in a schools SEND team writing a plan? Are they going to truly listen to children, young people and families and coproduce the contents. plans must be based on proper assessment and reflect professional evidence and the child/young person and families views.
16 How can we ensure Individual Support Plans are clear, concise and practical for professionals to use?
Please respond below::
Plans must be clear and specific.
Vague plans will not help children and young people to get the support that they require.
Words such as access to, as required, opportunities to, may need, etc create wiggle room for settings to not deliver the support that a child/young person requires.
Plans must be written in language that the setting and family can understand. They should say what support is needed, why, how it will be delivered and by whom.
There must be clear timescales for review.
It must also be clear that although a timescale for review is set, if the child/young persons needs are not being met, a review must be held at the earliest opportunity.
17 How can we best support transition for young people with SEND, so that they are well supported into post-16 provision and further
education, training or employment?
Please respond below::
Transition must begin early, and must be supported by clear and robust careers guidance that is appropriate for a young person with SEND.
Transition and preparation for adulthood must be embedded into the system, not a bolt-on when a young person becomes 14.
Transition must be holistic and multi-disciplinary, it must cover education and employment as well as health and social care transitions. Transition must encompass far more than just transition to the next setting, it must encompass wider skills of independence.
We must early identify those at risk of becoming NEET and put in place support.
Part two: new Targeted and Targeted Plus support that is written into law
18 How can we make sure that every area can meet the full range of the needs of children and young people through Inclusion Bases?
Please respond below::
Inclusion bases cannot meet the full range of needs proposed. There are children and young people who require smaller environments, specialist settings or therapeutic support.
Some children/young people for whom an inclusion base may help, will be those who internalise need and who may have anxiety or sensory needs, others may externalise and appear to have challenging behaviours in response to their needs. Putting these two cohorts into the same inclusion base will not work.
Inclusion Bases by their very nature are about segregation not inclusion. Putting a child/young person in a separate room or building within a mainstream environment is not inclusion it is segregation. How would a child/young person in this situation feel like they belong in the school? We should look at how the school environment as a who can be adapted- classrooms should be set up in different ways to be sensory friendly and adaptive to people’s needs. Why do we insist that children/young people must sit on a chair at a desk and look at the teacher? If a child/young person learns better sat on a bean bag, on the floor, under the table, looking away from the classroom why does this matter? We must focus on belonging.
It is also important to look at the accessibility of these bases. In rural areas it will be some distance between bases. For children/young people who need part-time access to a base, how will this work if the base in their local area focuses on a different type of need to theirs?
19 How can we make sure that Inclusion Bases help children and young people succeed in mainstream settings?
Please respond below::
Inclusion bases, firstly must be set up in an inclusive way- they must be sensory friendly and communication friendly environments.
They must be properly resourced, both with physical resources and with appropriate staffing, and the staff must have the appropriate training and access to the appropriate specialist support that they may need.
As already said, inclusion bases by their very nature segregate children and young people from the rest of the mainstream cohort. Bases must support the whole school to be more inclusive.
20 Through the Experts at Hand offer, we want to ensure that mainstream settings can get quick specialist support for children and young
people. What arrangements are needed between local area partners (education, health, social care) to deliver this Experts at Hand offer
effectively?
Please respond below::
There are currently significant shortages of the professionals required to be a part of the Experts at Hand offer- Educational Psychologists, Speech and Language Therapists, Occupational Therapists and others. To build the workforce the government must increase the number of university places for qualifying and must look at other routes to qualifications such as apprenticeships.
There must be accountability across the system to ensure that professionals are provided for these roles, and health systems and local authorities must work together to ensure there are not overlaps or gaps in service and there is a clear definition as to what Experts at Hand will deliver and what requires referrals into services.
Experts at Hand funding should also be extended for longer than three years. In three years time Experts at Hand will just be starting to be effective and make a difference and services will only just be starting to become fully staffed and resourced. Removing government funding at this point would undo all the work that will be started. Local Authorities current costs will not have yet started to reduce by putting in earlier support, so they will not have the finances to fund continuation of Experts at Hand.
Part three: specialist support for those with complex needs
21 What needs to be in place so that children and young people with low incidence, highly complex needs can always access the right
specialist placement?
Please respond below::
Firstly, there needs to be clarity around what low incidence, highly complex needs are. How will the system identify children and young people’s needs?
What about the children and young people who mask their needs or whose needs are misunderstood and labelled as behavioural issues.
There must be needs led decision making, children and young people must be able to access an appropriate education setting, not what setting has an available place.
Sufficiency of specialist places is a significant issue in some areas of the country.
22 How can Specialist Provision Packages be designed to effectively support the main types of need we currently recognise?
Please respond below::
We fundamentally disagree with the concept of Specialist Provision Packages.
Children and young people do not fit into neat boxes, and we should not attempt to shoehorn them into boxes.
This is a hugely backwards step moving away from individualised support.
There is no clarity as to who will be involved in the assessment to determine what package the child/young person receives, or what the thresholds for these will be.
23 We propose that EHCPs will guarantee educational provision set out in a Specialist Provision Package, with day-to-day provision captured in Individual Support Plans. What is needed to make these proposals work effectively?
Please respond below::
We disagree with this proposal- why create two separate plans for a child/young person?
If the EHCP only includes a package with the detail of the day-to-day provision that the child/young person needs then this is massively reducing children and young people’s rights.
The content and delivery of an Individual Support Plan is not enforceable.
This leaves families with no legal recourse if their child/young person is not receiving the support that the need.
24 We propose creating a more direct route to Specialist Provision Packages and EHCP assessments for children under 5 with complex needs.
How can we make sure this works in practice?
Please respond below::
In principle this is welcome- why leave children whose needs are clear to fail through levels before being able to access to further support.
However the detail here will be important- what is complex needs? Who is going to assess and make the decision? There should not be a description that is too narrow and does not allow for flexibility.
Early assessment and early identification of need must lead to early support being put in place for all children- those who meet the threshold for a Specialist Provision Packages and those who would be on Targeted or Targeted Plus levels.
25 What would you expect to be considered as part of the needs assessment, for example evidence and expert or professional input?
Please respond below::
A needs assessment must be holistic and consider the whole child/young person.
It should include the views of the child/young person and their parent carer.
Assessments should be multi-disciplinary encompassing input from educational psychology, occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, medical, social care and educational professionals.
Independent evidence must be considered equally.
Provision must be based on the needs of the child/young person- not on what provision is available or easy to deliver.
Part three: specialist support for those with complex needs
26 What factors should LAs take into account in proposing to parents and young people a list of potential settings to name on a plan?
Please respond below::
Local Authorities should start with the child/young persons needs and what provision they require to meet their needs- not just be focused on what a Specialist Provision Package suggests they may need.
Local Authorities must ONLY suggest provisions that can actually meet the assessed needs of the child/young person, and this must be clearly evidenced to parent carers and children and young people.
Decision making must be clear and transparent.
27 What information and support do parents need to make a decision about which setting will be best for their child?
Please respond below::
Parent carers need clear information, that is written in an accessible format and in accessible language.
There must be clarity about what a provision can offer- not just a type of need. For instance saying a school can meet the needs of children/young people with MLD, does not describe the provision and support the school can offer.
There must also be clarity around the cohort of children and young people who attend the provision.
There must be clear information about legal rights and access to independent information, advice and support.
28 What do you think is the right maximum length of time for a temporary placement in Alternative Provision (AP) schools? Please explain your rationale.
Please respond below::
This would vary from child to child. Arbitrary lengths of time being imposed can be detrimental to the child/young person.
What would be appropriate would be clear expectations about how often placements in alternative provision are reviewed, and clear supported transition plans out of AP.
29 We have set out our plans to regulate Independent Special Schools (ISS) sector. Do you agree that these proposed changes will lead to
suitable placements being available at a fair cost? Please explain why.
Please respond below::
The growth of the independent sector is because there are not enough maintained specialist school places.
Care must be taken to ensure that if costs are capped that they do not mean independent special schools, stop offering places leaving children and young people with no provision.
Whilst we agree that uncapped profits are driving up unstainable costs, the focus must be first and foremost on whether a setting can meet the needs of the child/young person.
Part four: reforming the system to reward inclusion
30 How should settings be held accountable for how they spend their Inclusive Mainstream funding?
Please respond below::
Funding must be linked to delivery and outcomes and there should be robust governance procedures in place to ensure that the funding is being spent in an effective way using the best evidence available.
There must be transparency in the system so that everyone, including families are aware of how funding is being spent and what should be delivered with the funding.
31 Do you agree that more SEND funding should sit directly within mainstream budgets? Please explain why.
Please respond below::
SEND funding should be ring-fenced. School budgets are already over-stretched.
There must be robust governance and transparency about how SEND funding is being spent, what is being delivered and what outcomes are being achieved.
32 In relation to pooled funding, we propose that every school becomes part of a local SEND group. Do you agree that this proposal aligns
with our aim for all schools to be part of high-quality, community-based trusts?
Please respond below::
Pooled funding may be difficult to achieve. Local groups of schools are likely to be across various different MATS, which may lead to difficulties with governance structures and account and audit processes.
Whilst pooling funding, for example to recruit a specialist to work over a group of schools would make sense, there needs to be clarity about how this would work practically and robust governance and transparency.
33 How should disagreements about membership, provision, or funding in groups of schools for SEND be resolved?
Please respond below::
Any disagreements should be resolved swiftly to ensure there is no delay to children and young people receiving the right support.
There should be clear transparency and communication about the process and the outcomes.
An independent decision maker should be involved,
There must be clear governance and pathways so that everyone knows where responsibility and accountability sits.
Part four: reforming the system to reward inclusion
34 How can we ensure the most effective use of these local partnership groups?
Please respond below::
Partnership groups must be a true partnership, with clear roles and responsibilities and shared accountability.
Partnership groups must focus on the needs of the children and young people, and keep them, their experiences and outcomes at the centre.
35 Which stakeholders are important for the success of local partnership groups, and why?
Please respond below::
Children, young people and parent carers.
Local Authorities- education, children’s social care, adult social care and employment and skills teams.
Integrated Care Boards
NHS trusts
Schools
Post-16 providers
Early years settings
Independent specialist settings
VCFSE
It must be a true partnership, will all partners treated equally.
36 How can we build stronger collaboration and a culture of improvement through local SEND strategic plans?
Please respond below::
We must work towards a culture of belonging, shared responsibility and shared accountability.
Improvement starts with a shared understanding of what is working and what is not working- both from a data perspective, but also from a lived experience perspective. Often systems think they are doing a good job, but the family and the child’s experience is very different.
37 What information, advice and guidance can best support children, young people and their families to ensure greater fairness across the
system?
Please respond below::
Families need accessible information, advice and support with the capacity to actually meet the needs of families.
38 Do you agree that a SEND specialist (e.g. a SENCO) should sit on the school complaint panel, when the complaint relates to SEND support
and provision? Please explain why.
Please respond below::
Yes there should be a SEND specialist however this must be independent. A SENCO at another school in the local area or within the same MAT, will not be seen as independent and parent carers will not have confidence in the process.
Aside from that we believe that complaints about the content or delivery of ISP’s should not sit within a school complaint process. It should be completely independent and statutory.
If disputes about a school, are handled by a school it will seen as a school marking its own homework. There will be no trust in the system and relationships between schools and families will be damaged.
Part four: reforming the system to reward inclusion
39 This consultation outlines a series of measures intended to reform the SEND system. Some of these measures have already been finalised,
and this is clearly indicated within the document. With this in mind, is there anything further you would like to contribute to help inform the
remaining proposals that are still under consideration?
Please respond below::
Accountability must be clear and shared across the system.
ISP’s must not only be a statutory document, but delivery of the provision in the ISP must be statutory and there must be independent appeal processes to appeal content and delivery.
Tribunals should be able to name a provision in Section I, otherwise families may end up going round in circles and children and young people not receiving the right support.
Assessments of need must be individual and children and young people must receive the support that they need- not be shoehorned into a box.
Children and families voices should be at the heart of the system, both at an individual and strategic level.
Children and families rights should not be reduced.
There is nothing wrong with Education, Health and Care Plans and the Children and Families Act 2014, the issue in the SEND system is the lack of consistency of provision being delivered at SEN Support level. Putting in place clear information about what must be delivered by a school through SEN Support, with clear accountability and making this statutory (supported by appropriate funding and training) would increase parental confidence in the system, increase inclusion in mainstream schools, and ultimately reduce EHCP’s and specialist placements. Strengthening through statutory means, early support and provision, rather than eroding families rights would be a better way of improving the SEND system and outcomes for children and young people.
local area and across the country. How can we make sure children, young people and their families have a genuine say in these decisions?
Please comment below::
Under the Children and Families Act 2014, children, young people and families already have a voice.
At an individual level, they must be involved in making decisions about the support they require at SEN Support and within assessments for Education, Health and Care Plans and in their reviews. The issue is not whether children and young people have a voice, it is whether their voices are listened to and genuinely ignored, or whether their voices are ignored and do not genuinely influence the decisions that are made about them.
At a strategic level parent carer voices are heard as part of parent carer forums, who listen to the voices of families across the area and represent these in a strategic way to influence service design and delivery. The challenge here is that parent carer forums are not properly resourced to undertake this work, and some parts of the system, despite coproduction and parent carer forums being in law since 2014, do not understand what coproduction is, and a culture in some areas of the system still exists where parent carers are not treated as professionals.
At both an individual and a strategic level there must be enforceability. There is no point in hearing children, young people and families voices if they are then ignored.
2 How can we make sure that high-quality evidence and best practice inform decisions about SEND? Please share examples.
Please respond below::
Making sure that high-quality evidence and best practice inform decisions about SEND is crucial, both at an individual level and for shaping wider systems.
At an individual level, parent carers and young people need to be confident that the support the child/young person receives is evidence based as is going to meet their needs. Often there is a vast amount of evidence about what a child or young person needs, however this can often be ignored in favour of what is easier, cheaper or allows a child to attend a mainstream setting. For instance a child might be pushed into a mainstream school to keep them “included” rather than being supported in a specialist setting where the evidence shows they would thrive. Decision making is not always about what is best for the child, but about convenience or cost.
At a strategic level, the tension between what would be best, and what is affordable is even more challenging. Service redesign and delivery often starts with “what can be done within a cost envelope” rather that what would best meet the needs of children and young people across the local area. Whilst we understand that there is not an unlimited amount of money, making decisions in silo’s based on cost, often pushes costs into other areas of the system for example putting funds into early identification of need and early support often prevents needs from escalating and prevents higher costs in the long run.
It is also essential that qualitative evidence is also considered.
Part one: putting children and young people first
3 How can we ensure that children are best supported by the Universal offer?
Please respond below::
A strong Universal Offer is essential, all too often what should be ordinarily available in schools is a postcode lottery. Children and young people should have access to the same education and support no matter what mainstream setting they attend.
However, at present this is variable across schools, and is based on the financial position of the school and the ethos and culture in the school.
Defining what the Universal offer is, is important, however this must be properly resourced in terms of funding, staffing and training and there must be accountability and enforcement.
SEND parent carers have very little trust that mainstream schools can meet the needs of their children and young people. This starts from the universal offer, and progresses through all levels.
4 How can we ensure that children in the Targeted layer are best supported?
Please respond below::
We do not believe that the system should create more layers, all too often layers become barriers- you have to try each layer and fail before moving onto the next level. We should be looking to put in place the right support, and the right time, in the right place, that best meets the needs of the child/young person. Support should be focused on what the child/young person needs rather than what level they fit into.
Additional support for children and young people must be timely, with no unnecessary bureaucracy and must be joined up between education, health and social care.
There must be seamless transitions between levels and swift access to more support where this is needed. There must be regular reviews of support, that include the child/young person and the parent carers.
It is vital that there are no arbitrary timeframes put in place- a child must not have to sit at a level of support for a mandated period of time if it is clear that this is not working.
There needs to be clear accountability and enforcement to ensure that support is put in place for children and young people.
5 How can we ensure that children in the Targeted Plus layer are best supported?
Please respond below::
The same concerns for the Targeted Layer apply to Targeted Plus. Support must be put in place early to prevent needs escalating. There must be clear accountability and enforcement to ensure that support is put in place for children and young people.
6 How can we ensure that children in the Specialist layer are best supported?
Please respond below::
Children and young people deemed to fit into the Specialist Layer are those described as complex, however with no definition of complex and no detail about how assessment of need will be undertaken.
All children and young people require accurate and detailed assessment of their needs, and clear and early identification of what support is required to meet those needs.
There is a real concern that children and young people will have to “fail” repeatedly through Universal, Targeted and Targeted Plus layers before they are able to get the support that they need.
Support needs to have clear accountability and enforcement to ensure that children and young people’s needs are met.
Part one: putting children and young people first
7 How do you think early years settings, schools, and colleges can best support the mental health and wellbeing of children and young
people?
Please respond below::
If settings support children and young people’s needs at the earliest possible opportunity, there is a lower likelihood they will develop mental health needs. Frequently children and young people’s emotional wellbeing and mental health suffers as a result of needs not being met.
Schools and settings are not mental health services and do not have the expertise or qualifications to be treated as such.
Ensuring support is put in place at the earliest possible opportunity, identifying children and young people’s needs early, so that they have a true understanding of themselves, and working to reduce bullying will reduce risk of children and young people having poor mental health. Wrapping mental health services around schools and settings will then support those who do have mental health needs.
We must be proactive and work to prevent mental health needs wherever possible rather than being reactive.
8 Do you agree that the refreshed ‘areas of development’ will support educators to understand and address barriers to learning and
participation? Please explain your answer.
Please respond below::
No, removing mental health from the areas of needs is a real risk.
Creating an area of need of Executive Function poses real difficulties as there is a lack of understanding as to what this means and what type of needs fall into this category.
Children and young people do not fall into neat boxes, often their needs are complex and sit across multiple areas, in some cases no-one can agree on a primary area of need for a child/young person.
Areas of development to not deliver provision and do not support a child/young person to receive the support they need, instead they label children unnecessarily.
9 What arrangements would best support effective joint working between early years providers, Best Start Family Hubs, health, local
authorities, and parents for children with SEND in the early years?
Please respond below::
Effective joint working requires a clear framework for responsibility and accountability.
It must be clear who should be doing what, when and what happens if it it not done.
There must be clear data-sharing arrangements and clear communication and transparency.
10 How can the early years foundation stage (EYFS) two-year old progress check and the Healthy Child Programme development review be improved so that children’s needs are identified and supported more quickly? Please share examples.
Please respond below::
These checks are an important part of the early identification of need and play a vital part of the system, however there must be clear pathways for the results of these checks to be passed on to education settings, health services and the local authority- there is no point having checks and identifying needs if that information is held in isolation.
There must be a focus on the early identification of need and then how early support is then put into place.
Part one: putting children and young people first
11 What should the top three priority areas be for building and sharing evidence within the National Inclusion Standards?
Please respond below::
Consistency of practice- so that every child/young person has access to the same support, no matter where they live or what setting they attend.
Accountability- ensuring there are clear accountability systems so that support is put into place to meet need at the earliest opportunity.
Prevention- early support to prevent escalation of need, is vital.
12 What are the most important issues for national training to cover, to help support children and young people with SEND?
Please respond below::
Neurodiversity and how to support children and young people in a neuro-affirming manner.
Sensory needs- how to identify sensory difficulties and create sensory friendly environments.
Communication needs- how to communicate is different ways to meet the needs of different children and young people.
Masking.
Burnout.
Anxiety.
Trauma.
Legal Duties
Training must be written in conjunction with those with lived experience.
13 What practical actions can help teachers, educators and leaders manage workload whilst implementing these changes?
Please respond below::
Staff in education settings are already stretched and their workload already unmanageable.
You cannot increase the workload that schools and settings are expected to do without increase the resources and capacity within the workforce.
These means protected time for training, additional teaching staff and support staff in schools.
Additional administrative support.
Importantly protected time for SENCO’s and support for them.
14 How should the Special Educational Needs Coordinator (SENCO) role evolve to better meet the needs of children and young people with SEND?
Please respond below::
SENCO’s are often expected to do multiple roles and have little protected time. Under the proposed reforms their workload will increase and this is not sustainable.
Settings should have protected SENCO time and resource- there should be a national standard as to how much SENCO time a setting should have based on the number of children and young people their setting has. This time should be protected.
SENCO’s must have the support in place to be able to do their role and proper training, not just the current SENCO qualification, but deeper training around different types of needs and strategies that can support needs. Training around how to work with, and coproduce with children, young people and families and training around person-centred planning.
Part two: new Targeted and Targeted Plus support that is written into law
15 What would provide assurance for families that an Individual Support Plan (ISP) is high quality and contains the essential information?
Please respond below::
There is not point putting in place a statutory document, if there is not accountability for the content of the plan and the delivery of the content.
Families need reassurance that they can appeal the content and the delivery through independent means- families do not trust that a school complaint process, even with an SEND expert on the panel is robust enough to do this.
Children and young people currently on SEN Support, typically have a plan (although called many different names) yet families currently do not have trust in these plans, which leads to the increase in requests for Education, Health and Care Plans. Creating a new document with no accountability will not change confidence in the system.
There needs to be a framework for who will input into these plans- is it just a teacher or someone in a schools SEND team writing a plan? Are they going to truly listen to children, young people and families and coproduce the contents. plans must be based on proper assessment and reflect professional evidence and the child/young person and families views.
16 How can we ensure Individual Support Plans are clear, concise and practical for professionals to use?
Please respond below::
Plans must be clear and specific.
Vague plans will not help children and young people to get the support that they require.
Words such as access to, as required, opportunities to, may need, etc create wiggle room for settings to not deliver the support that a child/young person requires.
Plans must be written in language that the setting and family can understand. They should say what support is needed, why, how it will be delivered and by whom.
There must be clear timescales for review.
It must also be clear that although a timescale for review is set, if the child/young persons needs are not being met, a review must be held at the earliest opportunity.
17 How can we best support transition for young people with SEND, so that they are well supported into post-16 provision and further
education, training or employment?
Please respond below::
Transition must begin early, and must be supported by clear and robust careers guidance that is appropriate for a young person with SEND.
Transition and preparation for adulthood must be embedded into the system, not a bolt-on when a young person becomes 14.
Transition must be holistic and multi-disciplinary, it must cover education and employment as well as health and social care transitions. Transition must encompass far more than just transition to the next setting, it must encompass wider skills of independence.
We must early identify those at risk of becoming NEET and put in place support.
Part two: new Targeted and Targeted Plus support that is written into law
18 How can we make sure that every area can meet the full range of the needs of children and young people through Inclusion Bases?
Please respond below::
Inclusion bases cannot meet the full range of needs proposed. There are children and young people who require smaller environments, specialist settings or therapeutic support.
Some children/young people for whom an inclusion base may help, will be those who internalise need and who may have anxiety or sensory needs, others may externalise and appear to have challenging behaviours in response to their needs. Putting these two cohorts into the same inclusion base will not work.
Inclusion Bases by their very nature are about segregation not inclusion. Putting a child/young person in a separate room or building within a mainstream environment is not inclusion it is segregation. How would a child/young person in this situation feel like they belong in the school? We should look at how the school environment as a who can be adapted- classrooms should be set up in different ways to be sensory friendly and adaptive to people’s needs. Why do we insist that children/young people must sit on a chair at a desk and look at the teacher? If a child/young person learns better sat on a bean bag, on the floor, under the table, looking away from the classroom why does this matter? We must focus on belonging.
It is also important to look at the accessibility of these bases. In rural areas it will be some distance between bases. For children/young people who need part-time access to a base, how will this work if the base in their local area focuses on a different type of need to theirs?
19 How can we make sure that Inclusion Bases help children and young people succeed in mainstream settings?
Please respond below::
Inclusion bases, firstly must be set up in an inclusive way- they must be sensory friendly and communication friendly environments.
They must be properly resourced, both with physical resources and with appropriate staffing, and the staff must have the appropriate training and access to the appropriate specialist support that they may need.
As already said, inclusion bases by their very nature segregate children and young people from the rest of the mainstream cohort. Bases must support the whole school to be more inclusive.
20 Through the Experts at Hand offer, we want to ensure that mainstream settings can get quick specialist support for children and young
people. What arrangements are needed between local area partners (education, health, social care) to deliver this Experts at Hand offer
effectively?
Please respond below::
There are currently significant shortages of the professionals required to be a part of the Experts at Hand offer- Educational Psychologists, Speech and Language Therapists, Occupational Therapists and others. To build the workforce the government must increase the number of university places for qualifying and must look at other routes to qualifications such as apprenticeships.
There must be accountability across the system to ensure that professionals are provided for these roles, and health systems and local authorities must work together to ensure there are not overlaps or gaps in service and there is a clear definition as to what Experts at Hand will deliver and what requires referrals into services.
Experts at Hand funding should also be extended for longer than three years. In three years time Experts at Hand will just be starting to be effective and make a difference and services will only just be starting to become fully staffed and resourced. Removing government funding at this point would undo all the work that will be started. Local Authorities current costs will not have yet started to reduce by putting in earlier support, so they will not have the finances to fund continuation of Experts at Hand.
Part three: specialist support for those with complex needs
21 What needs to be in place so that children and young people with low incidence, highly complex needs can always access the right
specialist placement?
Please respond below::
Firstly, there needs to be clarity around what low incidence, highly complex needs are. How will the system identify children and young people’s needs?
What about the children and young people who mask their needs or whose needs are misunderstood and labelled as behavioural issues.
There must be needs led decision making, children and young people must be able to access an appropriate education setting, not what setting has an available place.
Sufficiency of specialist places is a significant issue in some areas of the country.
22 How can Specialist Provision Packages be designed to effectively support the main types of need we currently recognise?
Please respond below::
We fundamentally disagree with the concept of Specialist Provision Packages.
Children and young people do not fit into neat boxes, and we should not attempt to shoehorn them into boxes.
This is a hugely backwards step moving away from individualised support.
There is no clarity as to who will be involved in the assessment to determine what package the child/young person receives, or what the thresholds for these will be.
23 We propose that EHCPs will guarantee educational provision set out in a Specialist Provision Package, with day-to-day provision captured in Individual Support Plans. What is needed to make these proposals work effectively?
Please respond below::
We disagree with this proposal- why create two separate plans for a child/young person?
If the EHCP only includes a package with the detail of the day-to-day provision that the child/young person needs then this is massively reducing children and young people’s rights.
The content and delivery of an Individual Support Plan is not enforceable.
This leaves families with no legal recourse if their child/young person is not receiving the support that the need.
24 We propose creating a more direct route to Specialist Provision Packages and EHCP assessments for children under 5 with complex needs.
How can we make sure this works in practice?
Please respond below::
In principle this is welcome- why leave children whose needs are clear to fail through levels before being able to access to further support.
However the detail here will be important- what is complex needs? Who is going to assess and make the decision? There should not be a description that is too narrow and does not allow for flexibility.
Early assessment and early identification of need must lead to early support being put in place for all children- those who meet the threshold for a Specialist Provision Packages and those who would be on Targeted or Targeted Plus levels.
25 What would you expect to be considered as part of the needs assessment, for example evidence and expert or professional input?
Please respond below::
A needs assessment must be holistic and consider the whole child/young person.
It should include the views of the child/young person and their parent carer.
Assessments should be multi-disciplinary encompassing input from educational psychology, occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, medical, social care and educational professionals.
Independent evidence must be considered equally.
Provision must be based on the needs of the child/young person- not on what provision is available or easy to deliver.
Part three: specialist support for those with complex needs
26 What factors should LAs take into account in proposing to parents and young people a list of potential settings to name on a plan?
Please respond below::
Local Authorities should start with the child/young persons needs and what provision they require to meet their needs- not just be focused on what a Specialist Provision Package suggests they may need.
Local Authorities must ONLY suggest provisions that can actually meet the assessed needs of the child/young person, and this must be clearly evidenced to parent carers and children and young people.
Decision making must be clear and transparent.
27 What information and support do parents need to make a decision about which setting will be best for their child?
Please respond below::
Parent carers need clear information, that is written in an accessible format and in accessible language.
There must be clarity about what a provision can offer- not just a type of need. For instance saying a school can meet the needs of children/young people with MLD, does not describe the provision and support the school can offer.
There must also be clarity around the cohort of children and young people who attend the provision.
There must be clear information about legal rights and access to independent information, advice and support.
28 What do you think is the right maximum length of time for a temporary placement in Alternative Provision (AP) schools? Please explain your rationale.
Please respond below::
This would vary from child to child. Arbitrary lengths of time being imposed can be detrimental to the child/young person.
What would be appropriate would be clear expectations about how often placements in alternative provision are reviewed, and clear supported transition plans out of AP.
29 We have set out our plans to regulate Independent Special Schools (ISS) sector. Do you agree that these proposed changes will lead to
suitable placements being available at a fair cost? Please explain why.
Please respond below::
The growth of the independent sector is because there are not enough maintained specialist school places.
Care must be taken to ensure that if costs are capped that they do not mean independent special schools, stop offering places leaving children and young people with no provision.
Whilst we agree that uncapped profits are driving up unstainable costs, the focus must be first and foremost on whether a setting can meet the needs of the child/young person.
Part four: reforming the system to reward inclusion
30 How should settings be held accountable for how they spend their Inclusive Mainstream funding?
Please respond below::
Funding must be linked to delivery and outcomes and there should be robust governance procedures in place to ensure that the funding is being spent in an effective way using the best evidence available.
There must be transparency in the system so that everyone, including families are aware of how funding is being spent and what should be delivered with the funding.
31 Do you agree that more SEND funding should sit directly within mainstream budgets? Please explain why.
Please respond below::
SEND funding should be ring-fenced. School budgets are already over-stretched.
There must be robust governance and transparency about how SEND funding is being spent, what is being delivered and what outcomes are being achieved.
32 In relation to pooled funding, we propose that every school becomes part of a local SEND group. Do you agree that this proposal aligns
with our aim for all schools to be part of high-quality, community-based trusts?
Please respond below::
Pooled funding may be difficult to achieve. Local groups of schools are likely to be across various different MATS, which may lead to difficulties with governance structures and account and audit processes.
Whilst pooling funding, for example to recruit a specialist to work over a group of schools would make sense, there needs to be clarity about how this would work practically and robust governance and transparency.
33 How should disagreements about membership, provision, or funding in groups of schools for SEND be resolved?
Please respond below::
Any disagreements should be resolved swiftly to ensure there is no delay to children and young people receiving the right support.
There should be clear transparency and communication about the process and the outcomes.
An independent decision maker should be involved,
There must be clear governance and pathways so that everyone knows where responsibility and accountability sits.
Part four: reforming the system to reward inclusion
34 How can we ensure the most effective use of these local partnership groups?
Please respond below::
Partnership groups must be a true partnership, with clear roles and responsibilities and shared accountability.
Partnership groups must focus on the needs of the children and young people, and keep them, their experiences and outcomes at the centre.
35 Which stakeholders are important for the success of local partnership groups, and why?
Please respond below::
Children, young people and parent carers.
Local Authorities- education, children’s social care, adult social care and employment and skills teams.
Integrated Care Boards
NHS trusts
Schools
Post-16 providers
Early years settings
Independent specialist settings
VCFSE
It must be a true partnership, will all partners treated equally.
36 How can we build stronger collaboration and a culture of improvement through local SEND strategic plans?
Please respond below::
We must work towards a culture of belonging, shared responsibility and shared accountability.
Improvement starts with a shared understanding of what is working and what is not working- both from a data perspective, but also from a lived experience perspective. Often systems think they are doing a good job, but the family and the child’s experience is very different.
37 What information, advice and guidance can best support children, young people and their families to ensure greater fairness across the
system?
Please respond below::
Families need accessible information, advice and support with the capacity to actually meet the needs of families.
38 Do you agree that a SEND specialist (e.g. a SENCO) should sit on the school complaint panel, when the complaint relates to SEND support
and provision? Please explain why.
Please respond below::
Yes there should be a SEND specialist however this must be independent. A SENCO at another school in the local area or within the same MAT, will not be seen as independent and parent carers will not have confidence in the process.
Aside from that we believe that complaints about the content or delivery of ISP’s should not sit within a school complaint process. It should be completely independent and statutory.
If disputes about a school, are handled by a school it will seen as a school marking its own homework. There will be no trust in the system and relationships between schools and families will be damaged.
Part four: reforming the system to reward inclusion
39 This consultation outlines a series of measures intended to reform the SEND system. Some of these measures have already been finalised,
and this is clearly indicated within the document. With this in mind, is there anything further you would like to contribute to help inform the
remaining proposals that are still under consideration?
Please respond below::
Accountability must be clear and shared across the system.
ISP’s must not only be a statutory document, but delivery of the provision in the ISP must be statutory and there must be independent appeal processes to appeal content and delivery.
Tribunals should be able to name a provision in Section I, otherwise families may end up going round in circles and children and young people not receiving the right support.
Assessments of need must be individual and children and young people must receive the support that they need- not be shoehorned into a box.
Children and families voices should be at the heart of the system, both at an individual and strategic level.
Children and families rights should not be reduced.
There is nothing wrong with Education, Health and Care Plans and the Children and Families Act 2014, the issue in the SEND system is the lack of consistency of provision being delivered at SEN Support level. Putting in place clear information about what must be delivered by a school through SEN Support, with clear accountability and making this statutory (supported by appropriate funding and training) would increase parental confidence in the system, increase inclusion in mainstream schools, and ultimately reduce EHCP’s and specialist placements. Strengthening through statutory means, early support and provision, rather than eroding families rights would be a better way of improving the SEND system and outcomes for children and young people.